A.
Treatment of Organic Diseases
Every case of illness depends in large measure in its phenomenology and
in its aspect, as has been repeatedly stated by one of the present authors on
the central attitude of the personality. It is by no means correct in every
case to speak of psychogenic additions. Even aside from the question of whether
psychotherapy can or can not affect the fundamental trouble, it will be in a
position to attain important results by influencing the individual attitude
This is true for instance, of the troubles of cardiac patients and of the
terrified expectations that such patients have of their disease which
sometimes, under the aspect of anxiety neurosis completely dominate the
external picture of the disease. In many cases simply admonition, persuasion,
or the like will be sufficient to influence the patient's. attitude favorably.
Frequently, however, hypnosis will be necessary, which must be used with due
tact and caution. Particularly in such cases it will as a rule be wrong to undertake extensive
psychoanalysis. the diseases to which such treatments may be applied—and they
must be effective after three or four sessions—are diseases of the
joints and bones, carcinosis, etc. Of the diseases of the nervous system,
particular attention is deserved by multiple sclerosis, whose symptoms are so
emphatically shot through with psychogenic factors. We have already emphasized
the fact that the patient's attitude is of importance in any organic disease,
which by no means gives us the right to speak at once of hysteria, or similar
conditions, merely because the will may not be strong enough to compensate
organic disturbances. Even the will to compensate organic disturbances of
equilibrium may be considerably improved by psychotherapy. The striking
successes so often observed at the beginning of treatment of tabes dorsalis by
exercise may perhaps be best explained in this way. The patient will
occasionally too early relinquish the struggle against a symptom that would be
quite easily compensated with proper guidance and with a proper attitude on his
part. In certain domains of apparently organic diseases it is difficult to draw
the line between the organic and the functional. This is particularly true of
diseases of the intestines. We have pointed out in detail above how strong is
the influence of the psychic element on motility and on secretion of the
gastric juices. Even unquestionably organic alterations in the domain of the
abdominal tract, such as dilatation and ptosis of the stomach do not put in
their appearance until psychic factors are added. The violent vomiting(*) of
such patients, their hardly bearable pains, often disappear with striking
swiftness in hypnotic treatment, which must be adapted to the principles of the
treatment of neuroses. Cases of hyperemesis gravidarum, even such as
include in their origin toxic factors in addition to the psychic, are favorable
subjects of hypnotic therapy. Certain forms of constipation, as has been
pointed out by Forel, and as we may confirm, are very frequently susceptible to
favorable treatment by psychic means. Nor will profound hypnosis always be
necessary in these cases. Many of the cases of abdominal and intestinal
neuroses, with more or less pronounced organic symptoms, must of course be
classed as neuroses, and these require the entire armamentarium of neurotic
therapy, i.e., the more serious cases will not yield except to
psychoanalysis. But excellent results may be obtained, even in acute cases, by
hypnosis alone. Thus we
succeeded in obtaining immediate
results by means of two seances in a case of singultus(**) with
sarco-matosis of the peritoneum, which had ensued upon an ether narcosis
administered for the purpose of precise investigation and had resisted all
other treatment. In the gynecological field, leucorrhea, menstrual troubles,
hyperemesis gravidarum, have been repeatedly treated with success by Forel,
Hallauer, Lieptmann, Meyer. We shall say a few words later on treatment of
vaginal anesthesia. In the treatment of such disturbances, we shall probably
need to ask always what phases of these disturbances may be regarded as organic
neurosis, in other words, as a neurosis localized to a specific organ, and what
phases must be considered as distinctly organic disturbances. If the organic
neurotic phase predominates, the general principles of neurotic treatment must
be applied, of which we shall speak later in the proper connection. Bunnemann
reports on the influence of hysteria on skin diseases.(***)
(*) One case of mine with
chronic vomiting and inability to retain food for a period of five months was
quickly helped with hypnotic suggestion gotten from psychoanalytic study of the
causes of this condition.—Trans.
(*)In several cases of
singultus, of epidemic origin, hypnosis was very effectual.—Trans.
(**) In one case of
angioneurotic edema and urticaria, hypnosis was tried but without success,
though it is possible that the psychic approach in the suggestion was
faulty.—Trans.
Bronchial asthma may in some cases be influenced by hypnosis, yet this
influence is apparently not easy to attain; we have had no successes in this
field.
Even disturbances of the vegetative nervous system, not recognizable as
psychogenic, such as, for example, hyperhydrosis, are sometimes influenced by
profound hypnosis.
Kohnstamm and Friedermann report a cure of exophthalmic goiter by means
of hypnoses. But the normal treatment for Basedow's disease of course does not
require hypnosis.
All the possible phases of psychic treatment are treated in detail in
the material collected in O. Schwartz's Psychogenese und Psycho-therapie von
Organsymptomen. We refer the reader to this work, but must point out that
the contributors of the various articles have far too low an estimate
of the method of treating
by regular psychoanalysis. We consider this method to be a royal remedy in the
treatment of serious neurotic troubles, regardless of whether they result in
organic symptoms or not. Hypnosis is only the method for easy and medium cases
and may have great symptomatic value even in the treatment of serious cases.
|